When it comes to tires, there is now more choice on the market than ever before. You have a choice of premium luxury/premium tires that are the most efficient. You can also choose a budget version of a premium tire that sacrifices top performance and grip, but still offers a lot of work.
You can also swap in cheap tires that are suitable for most situations, but not for those that drive a lot of miles. You can get cheap sub-brand tires like Arizona-made tires for a very low price, which are not the best anywhere, but the price is attractive. In this comparison between Arizona and Goodyear tires, we pit the low-priced tire brands against the world’s largest tire manufacturer. We’ll tell you what you get for paying double or even triple the amount, and if that’s what you should.
Arizona Tire History
Almost everyone is aware of the Cooper Tire and Rubber Company because it has been around since World War I. Cooper not only produces Cooper brand tires, but also many other tires that most of us know like Mickey Thompson, Avon, Dean, Roadmaster, Starfire, and finally Arizona Tires.
Arizona Tires is a special low-cost economy tire brand that can only be obtained through Discount Tire. These brands are not limited to Cooper, but Goodyear does the same thing, making Douglas tires that are only available through Walmart. As such, these tires are only available in the US, and it’s safe to say that many Americans will be buying them.
The brand was established in the 1960s and has been continuously available through Discount Tire (America’s Tire) since then. The philosophy behind these tires is that they are manufactured to the latest safety standards and can be purchased by almost anyone. These tires cost significantly less compared to even the cheap Chinese brands, which aren’t that much better. This means that these tires are perfect for those who do not drive very many kilometres and those who have an old car and do not want to spend too much money on tires. They will satisfy most riders in normal dry conditions, but things change when you encounter rain and snow.
Arizona Tires Family of tires
Arizona Tires is a brand that can only be obtained through Discount Tire (America’s Tire), which means that if you are interested in purchasing them, you should check out the Discount Tire website. It’s worth mentioning that Arizonian only offers a handful of tire series, and only two of them are currently available.
1. Arizona Silver Edition all season long
The Arizonian Silver Edition All-Plastic tire promises all the bells and whistles, but without the price tag that usually comes with top-of-the-line tires. Arizona says the Silver Edition all-around tire is designed for those who want year-round reliability and can handle anything. Of course, this is not true, because the tire simply cannot withstand everything, especially in winter.
The good thing about the Arizona Silver Edition All Season tire is that it fits everything from cars to SUVs and trucks. Based on most reviews online, people seem to be mostly happy with this tire, especially in the dry. When it comes to wet roads, snow, ice, or general noise and comfort, the Silver Edition All Season simply cannot compete with the best brands. See the latest price
2. Arizona Silver Edition III
Arizonian Silver Edition III is the newest tire from Arizonian. This touring all-season tire is suitable for most passenger cars, minivans, and sedans, but not for larger vehicles such as SUVs and trucks. The Silver Edition III also looks like a pretty nice tire that just won’t break when exposed to rain and imperfect asphalt quality.
The Silver Edition III is an improvement over the original Silver Edition tire, especially in terms of comfort, tread, and wet grip. However, the tire was widely criticized for its poor snow and ice performance, making it pointless to use these tires in deep snow. Some also said that Arizona should offer more of these sizes.
At the birth of the 20th century, a man called Frank Seiberling founded the Goodyear Tire company in Ohio, USA. The company got its name from Charles Goodyear who was the very first person to ever manufacture vulcanized rubber. Since 1898 to this very day, Goodyear has stayed on the top of the tire industry, and it seems like they are not going anywhere anytime soon.
Before WW1 snuck around the corner, Goodyear was busy inventing the very first tubeless tire and they were also the very first company to ever manufacture an airplane tire in 1909. The Ford Model T rolled out of the production facility in 1908 and it features tires made by Goodyear. After the end of the First World War, Goodyear was on the rise, because by 1926 they had become the largest tire manufacturer in the world.
However, Goodyear never stopped innovating as they were also the first company to release nylon tires in 1947. Less than 20 years later, Goodyear celebrated the production of their billionth tire, something that many tire manufacturers have failed to do. this very day. It was also a time when Goodyear invested heavily in motorsport, which they have never abandoned, even to this day.
In 2022, Goodyear is as strong as ever thanks to its deep investments in all aspects of the automotive and aircraft tire industry. They offer many tire families, tire series, tire sub-series, sub-brands, motorcycle tires, commercial tires, and pretty much everything else that is made out of rubber.
Goodyear Tire Family
We have already mentioned a few times that Goodyear is a colossal company. This means that they encompass pretty much the entire market including niche markets. No matter if you need a tire for a car, an airplane, a van, an RV, a motorcycle, or an off-road project car, Goodyear has got you covered. However, here we are only going to list tires that are available for passenger cars, SUVs, trucks, and crossovers.
Touring tires are what Goodyear is known for and the Goodyear Assurance range is what most people want. The Assurance collection is designed with longevity, sophistication, and flexibility in mind. These tires aren’t far off from some dedicated performance tires, which means you’re getting a tire that can do just about anything.
The Assurance range includes several sub-models such as Assurance Fuel Max, Assurance MaxLife, Assurance Finesse, Assurance Weather Ready, and Assurance Comfort Drive. They can be installed in almost any car and come in different shapes and sizes.
1. Goodyear Eagle
If you want a purpose-built performance tire that can stand up to the world’s most decorated performance tires, Goodyear Eagle tires are the way to go. These tires can be found everywhere from Project MX-5 Miata track toys to multi-million dollar supercars. The best thing about the Goodyear Eagle is that they don’t sacrifice comfort for focus.
The Eagle line consists of Eagle Sport, Eagle F1, Eagle LS, Eagle NCT, Eagle GR, Eagle RS, and Eagle Exhilarate tires. They also come in different shapes and sizes, with sub-models emphasizing different priorities such as longevity, comfort, or maximum grip. See the latest price
2. Goodyear Ultra Grip
Goodyear is a huge tire company, which means they have tires for almost every use, including winter. The Goodyear Ultra Grip is a purpose-built winter tire designed to handle snow, ice, slush, dirt, grime, and everything else you’ll encounter. However, these tires shine best in dry grip, which cannot be compared to special winter tires.
The Ultra Grip collection consists of Ultra Grip GW2/3, Ultra Grip Ice WRT, and regular Ultra Grip winter tires. They are available for all types of cars, including small cars, large cars, vans, SUVs, trucks, and even special off-road vehicles. See the latest price
3. Goodyear Winter Command
The Goodyear Ultra Grip isn’t the only winter tire you can get from Goodyear, as they also have the Goodyear Winter Command tire. The Winter Command collection differs from the Ultra Grip in that it is also available with studs that are unmatched on ice. However, they are limited in size and do not fit many vehicles.
4. Goodyear Wrangler
The Goodyear Wrangler is one of the most famous off-road tires in the world, as it can be found on almost every off-road bike on every off-road trail. They can be mounted on anything with more ground, and there aren’t many off-road specialty tires that are as common as the Goodyear Wrangler.
The reason why the Wrangler is such a success for Goodyear is that it offers unrivalled traction in various off-road situations and because it comes in around 20 different sub-models and variations. Furthermore, the Wrangler lineup also offers dedicated extreme off-road tires and even extreme mud tires.
5. Goodyear Efficient Grip and Goodyear Excellence
The Goodyear Efficient Grip family of tires is designed with efficiency and touring in mind, but without compromising on performance and traction. However, these aren’t as widely available as other Goodyear touring tires because they only come in two different variations. One is an all-season tire while the other one is a performance touring tire. Both of these are found in almost all passenger cars.
The Goodyear Excellence Touring tire range is very similar to the Goodyear Efficient Grip, but the Excellence is available in more sizes and is generally a more refined tire. Goodyear Fierce
If you have a truck/van that you love to take to an off-road course while maintaining daily use, the Goodyear Fierce line is what you should be looking for. These tires are made with serious terrain in mind, but are surprisingly comfortable and quiet, especially at highway speeds. As such, they are only available for trucks and SUVs.
6. Goodyear Frontier
The Goodyear Frontera line is designed for those who drive SUVs and trucks but never drive them off-road. These tire families are designed with comfort and refinement in mind, which means they aren’t the best off-roaders. Because most people do not buy SUVs and trucks for off-roading these days, they have proven to be a success with Goodyear like Goodyear Eagle LS 2 Tire Review. They are available in SL (Sport) and HL (Highway) versions.
7. Goodyear Integrity
The Goodyear Integrity tire range is Goodyear’s entry-level tire designed to be affordable and widely available for all types of cars. The Goodyear Integrity line offers all-around tires that are sophisticated and don’t cost a lot of money.
Differences between Arizona Tires and Goodyear
This is part of our Arizona Vs Goodyear tire comparison where we pit the two brands against each other and see which is the best.
When it comes to dry grip, the Arizona Tires are probably the best, which means they perform great, especially for the price. But none of the tires discussed in this article can match the Goodyear Eagle for dry grip, and especially not a tire made in Arizona. Wet grip is where the Assurance line wipes the floor with the Arizonian, and that’s the case with nearly all Goodyear touring tires.
Off-roading is a one-sided story, as the Goodyear Wrangler and Fierce lineups are no match for the Arizona. Winter tires are also a one-sided story, as there are not too many premium brands on the market that can compete with Goodyear in winter, not to mention economy brands.
In general, the Arizona tires are good in the dry, and decent in the wet. Goodyear Tires, on the other hand, excels at everything.
Availability is where a big tire brand like Goodyear can win all the awards because Goodyear offers a wide range of tires in every class. They have a tire for almost everything you need. On the other hand, the Arizona Silver Edition line is available for many cars, but they are not on the same level as Goodyear tires.
Price and warranty
In terms of price, Arizona tires are up to three times lower than Goodyear tires in the same tire categories. This is a huge price difference that simply cannot be ignored. However, you get what you pay for, as most of Goodyear’s premium tires are far better than anything Arizona has ever produced.
The warranty is not as one-sided as we expected, as the Arizona tires come with a rather commendable 65,000-mile wear warranty. This is somewhat surprising, as many cheap tire brands do not have a warranty. On the other hand, Goodyear Assurance MaxLife tires have a record 80,000-mile wear rating.
Advantages of Arizona tires
- You can get them from anywhere in the US through Discount Tire
- Good for an old car that doesn’t drive many miles
- Good warranty for the price
Advantages of Goodyear tires
- Better performance
- Better warranty
- More options
- Everything else
Which brand to choose?
Goodyear is the better brand and there is no getting around it. While Arizona tires can benefit some people, Goodyear tires can benefit everyone. The price may be a bit high for some models, but if you want the best, you have to pay for it.
At the end of the Arizona vs. Goodyear tire comparison, it’s safe to say that Goodyear is the better manufacturer between the two, but sometimes it makes sense to choose Arizona tires instead.