What Is The Difference Between All Season And Winter Tires

What Is The Difference Between All Season And Winter Tires

The tires are considered the main part of the vehicle, the rotation and forward movement of the vehicle depends upon the vehicle’s tires.

The tires manufacturing industries design a variety of tires as per requirements for road conditions, driving style, and especially season variation.

So here we are going to discuss all-season tires and winter tires.

Winter tires are specially designed for snow and ice traction while All-season tires have shows all-season traction and grip.

The main difference between all season and winter tires cannot be observed at first seen.

While the big difference between all-season and winter tires is the tread design.

The molds used for tread designing differentiate the performance and handling of both tires.

14 Rating12 Rating
M+S symbol on tires side walls.Three-peak mountain snowflake symbol or tires
More durable tread rubber. The manufacturing compound of the tread will harden the rubber in cold weather.Less durable than all-season tread. The manufacturing company keeps the rubber flexible in cold weather.
60 mph in 22.9 sec and stops at a distance of 421 feet.60 mph in 19.1 sec and stop at a distance of 382 feet.
60 mph in 15.4 sec. The stopping distance is 215 feet.60 mph in 12.7 sec. The stopping distance is 181 feet.
60 mph in 8.7 sec. The stopping distance is 1531 feet.60 mph in 8.9 sec. The stopping distance is 155 feet.

Rubber Compound Used For The Construction Of Tires For Cold Weather

In cold weather, the construction compound of All-season tread rubber and summer tires tread rubber hardens at high temperatures as compared to the winter or snow tires and does not remain able to perform better performance.

In general, the tread rubber of all-season tires becomes hardened when the temperature falls from 42 degrees Fahrenheit.

Tire rubber must be able to maintain a strong grip and Traction in cold temperatures.

The Winter tires and the All-season tires show the same winter Traction.

But as the temperature falls the grip and Traction of winter tires becomes more strong while the All-season tire’s traction shows a decline in traction.

When mercury is upper than 42 degrees Fahrenheit, the rubber compound of All-season tires shows excellent traction and strong grip, While the rubber of winter tires becomes softened and does not maintain its shape, and frequent wearing out is observed.

This is the reason for removing the winter tires in the off-season is recommended.

In the early spring season, it should be removed and in late fall when temperatures start to fall from 42 degrees Fahrenheit, it should be installed.

Tread Pattern For Strong Grip On Snow Covered Terrains

Another feature that ensures snow traction is a mold used to give the tread pattern.

In general, the tread pattern of summer tires has wide circumferential grooves that act as a barrier between solid ribs that are engineered in summer tires.

This tread pattern ensures a long tread life, provides fuel-efficient drive and quite smooth rides have been experienced.

The regular all-season tires featured solid tread blocks, with wide grooves that are installed in the chevron-shaped pattern.

This type of tread pattern help in the evacuation of water from inside the tread.

For snow Traction, these tires’ treads need more biting edges that cut the snow and provide a strong grip.

The tire’s Manufacturer installed the narrow slits in the tread pattern that provide snow traction.

Sometimes the overall features of these tires are based on these fine slits.

The tread design also has sipes. These sipes increase the density of biting edges.

They provide integrity to the tire tread for excellent handling and stability and also help in lowering the noise level.

What Is Tire Markings

The tire’s name and the marking on the sides of the tread wall verify the use of the tire.

A common verification marking on a snow tire is the Three Peak Mountain snowflake sign, which verifies the tire’s indication on snow and ice-covered terrains.

The Rubber Manufacturer’s Association of America and the Rubber Association of Canada provide the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol to tires, which ensures that the tires meet all the requirements and quality specifications for winter performance.

You will never get this verification symbol on an all-season tire. While the All-season tires have an M+S marking, Which ensures the tire’s ability on muddy and snowy pavements.

However, the M+S marked on all-season tires is not a good indicator for snow and ice-covered road traction. So you might avoid the M+S marking tires in winter weather.

Tread Design

The tread pattern of all-season tires is designed for traction in dry, wet, and snow weather.

They are featured with medium-sized tread blocks and grooves with more biting edges than summer tires.

These biting edges are not enough for snow and ice traction.

While the winter tires are Specially designed with dense biting edges that provide a strong grip and stability on a snow and ice-packed road.

This type of Traction cannot be possible with all-season tires.


In Cold weather, the snow and winter ice show an excellent performance than All-season tires.

Winter tires covered 0-60 mph (miles per hour) in 19.1 sec, which is better than 60 mph (miles per hour) in the 22.9-sec performance of the All-season tires.

The braking distance observed with an all-season tire is 421 feet while the winter tires stop at 382 feet.

In rainy weather, the acceleration of snow tires is recorded as 0-60 mph in 12.7 sec.

While the All-season tire’s acceleration took 15.4 sec for 60 mph.

The stopping distance for Winter tires is 181 feet while 215 feet for All-season tires.

In dry conditions, the acceleration of winter tires is measured as 8.9 sec for 60 mph and the All-season tires show 8.7 sec.

The stopping distance of winter tires is 155 feet while the All-season tires stopped after 131 feet.

Safety Concerns

In cold weather, Winter or Snow tires are considered for safe driving. The safety measures are 38% more with Winter tires as compared to All-season tires.


You can install a set of All-season tires for 60 – 125 dollars. The All-season tire replacement is required after every 3 years.

The set of winter tires can be installed for 65 – 120 dollars, and they don’t need replacement in the next six years.

It can save you 75 dollars, which is the expense of changing tires per time.

Thank you for reading!

Add comment